Blogs

Regional Racism – Does it exist?

Posted on

4 Comments

There aren’t many that would argue that the City of Liverpool has fared well in the manner in which it, and its people, have been depicted by television companies eager to caricature Scousers.

But despite the often negative stereotype of Liverpudlians – does regional racism exist?   To begin with, the terminology might be a little clumsy – after all racism is prejudice by one race against another – but it is evidentially an “ism” of one sort or another, when people that have never visited the City have predetermined ideas about its inhabitants based on a portrayal of their character through the prism of TV – or worse – tabloid lies.

Perhaps this phenomenon is uniquely Scouse-ism – although Brummies, Geordies, Mancunians, Glaswegians and Yorkshire folk may also argue that there is often bias leveled against their peoples and places.  But in my home city there is a proof beyond doubt that a single issue stereotype exists which has influenced people’s perceptions right across the length and breadth of the country.   It would be a fair bet that if a survey were to be carried out asking - 'in which city would people expect to be the victim of car crime' - that Liverpool would be at the top of that unenviable league table. And yet, the facts contradict this mis-perception as Liverpool doesn’t even rate in the top 20 metropolitan areas for theft from cars.

Despite this flawed supposition, it is difficult to get people to change their minds once they are made up, but there is a reason why some believe fiction over fact.

For many years negative stereotypes have been perpetuated by comedians desperate for an easily recognisable caricature.  In pubs and clubs throughout the land many comics specifically target groups by exaggerating their characteristics. A type of comedic inverted snobbery forms the basis of humour the World over.  The French and Belgium’s skit at each other, the Americans make disparaging comments about Canadians and for many years, British comedians told inappropriate stories about “thick” Irishmen.

At a micro level, villages have been playing one-upmanship with their neighbouring communities by apocryphal tales of the village idiot.  Even in the Simpsons cartoon, Springfield residents poke fun at their ‘carbon-copy’ neighborhood of Shelbyville.  But it is almost universally accepted (if not acceptable) that jokes about cars being robbed are typically prefixed by the location of this crime being identified as Liverpool.

One of the oldest gags that still does the rounds is where the comic mentions that he/she had recently visited Liverpool and concludes by trotting out the old cliché that they were only there to "visit their hubcaps"!

Despite the tried and tested comedy formulae of a ‘set-up’ and ‘punchline’ – the joke itself portrays how old and tired the content is.  It is many decades since cars actually had hub-caps – and so, upon further examination it would appear that the origins of this gag may be some 40 – 50 years old.  And yet, is it still funny? Certainly it is still being used and getting laughs – so it must be humorous at one level.

Liverpudlians are renowned for their sense of humour – and yet when hackneyed stereotypes are challenged, we are described as being overly defensive and sensitive.  Some are more forthright in their criticism of our communal consciousness and believe it highlights a 'chip on our shoulder”' attitude.   Boris Johnson (now there is a stereotype!) famously insulted the City by describing its people of “wallowing in self-pity” and of having a victim mentality.

Conveniently for Boris this placed us in a very invidious position.  If we challenged his hypothesis – it could be argued that this was displaying the very trait he identified in our psyche, but if we said nothing, his critique would self evidently be right as it hadn’t been challenged.  There is no doubt that the people of Liverpool do stand up for themselves when faced with criticism of our City, but is this a demonstration of our ‘chippy-ness’, or of our undoubted affection for the place of our birth?

For scousers this is a proverbial catch-22 situation – a self-fulfilling prophecy if ever there was one.  But Scousers did defend themselves and Johnson was forced to make a very public apology.   It is therefore important for us to ensure that any defense of our City’s reputation is well considered as it might simply reinforce his postulation.  So despite the fact that car crime is below the national average, and that cars haven’t had hub-caps for decades, are perceptions of Liverpool evidence that regional prejudice exists?   

The only people that can accurately judge our actual state of mind are the millions of visitors to our City each year.  On occasion, like in every developed country in the World, cars will be broken into, or stolen.  The situation then is – does the victim believe they were the unfortunate victim of car crime that could happen anywhere, or that the incident simply reinforces the perception of some - that there is an inevitability of such incidents occurring, due to our undeserved reputation as the car crime capital of the UK?

 

Add a comment:

Leave a comment:

Comments

  1. nicola

    I am a single mum now living in Southport for 4years.. however my mum & dad have lived her 10 years. Through my period of time living here I believe I have been a victim through my background or my circumstances hence the stereotypical views apon this. However I have tryed to ignore this to a certain level but I'm sure regional rascism has been projected on to me where it has gone as deep to putting this on to my child. Its not just only myself that has felt like this but a lot of single parents I know that have felt the same way. I think its realy rotten why all people despite background or were their from are to be judge regardless of races or regional positioning! Why are people feeling this type of discomfort because everyone should work as one to become a better society to live in.. realy sad that a divide should continue in this way & I would love to bring more awareness to this type of divide people seem to pecieve after all the 2012 Olympics created a view point to bring people together and not to go against eachother regarding race or regional positioning.. why carnt everyone been seen in an individual unique way:)

    Posted on

  2. Neil

    Scousers are the worst for this! I live and work in Liverpool and I am constantly ridiculed for being from out the area. Scousers give a lot more than they take!!

    Posted on

  3. Miguel

    Nice post Steve. However, please note the magazine that Boris Johnson (a walking stereotyped indeed, as you write) edited published the Bigley editorial. He did not write it. And it was his then Tory leader boss, Michael Howard, who forced him up to Liverpool to apologise. Contrary to stereotyped, assumptions the editorial and Johnson's visit were largely ignored in Liverpool.

    Posted on

  4. mary roberts

    hi Steve. your blog is absolutely spot on, a great read, i agree wholeheartedly with you. this city does get discriminated against but as proven in the past as a city when we need to we stand up and be counted as one, we wont let anyone trample on us and God knows plenty have tried over the years. You wouldn't get that down south. i know where i'd rather live! ynwa

    Posted on

Add a comment